Stories include: tribal wind projects in the US; hydro-electric projects which have oppressed Guatemalan communities, solar project for cultural survival in Altai, and energy sovereignty in North-eastern Siberia. Made with dear friend Randall Wood and the UNU team in Tokyo, the work evolved through the collaborative efforts of several indigenous groups connected to UNU-IAS TKI and the generous creative commons community on Vimeo. It premiered in English with Italian subtitles. You can download your own version of the multilingual DVD here.
Well done everyone!
The Think Forward Film Festival was established in Venice in 2011, with the aim to study, discuss, and disseminate climate change as well as the issues related to energy efficiency and renewable energythrough both short and feature films. The Think Forward Film Festival is a project of the International Center for Climate Governance(ICCG), a joint initiative of Fondazione Eni Enrico Mattei (FEEM) and Fondazione Giorgio Cini, now an internationally renowned centre whose research activities focus on the design of climate policy and governance. The festival will feature films and documentaries as well as a selection of the best short films from the competition, new to this second edition. There will be side events such as meetings and discussions with directors and actors. Some activities will be aimed to inform both students and teachers on issues related to climate change and renewable energy sources in order to both increase awareness as well as to encourage discussions on these topics among young people. The Think Forward Film Festival has made sustainability its founding principle, for instance, by printing materials on FSC-certified recycled paper, using zero kilometre catering, and preferring to use digital communication to air travel when organising events. http://thinkforwardfestival.it/home-en/the-festival/
And I was rewarded with what I heard. After doing one-man-band interviewing of community knowledge custodians, ethnographic academics, IPCC lead authors and the Chair of the UN Permanent Forum on Indigenous Issues, it was as though, all of the hard climate study so far was verified. The meeting’s technical report and outcomes plus the humbly created voxpop interviews are yet to come but in the meantime there were two things I wanted to share…
After listening to case studies from the Arctic Reindeer Herders and Inuit Ocean Hunters, African subtropical pastoralists, Andes-Amazonian watershed farmers to Micronesian ocean navigating fisher people, there was wide suggestion amongst the group that Indigenous seasonal calendars across the world are drastically changing and possibly systematically collapsing. It is worth thinking about because this emerging trend in global research evidence may have enormous institutional and structural implications for everyone (think both local and industrialised food systems and security). Importantly, its also worth thinking about for Indigenous communities, because known traditional knowledge adaptation methods are already heavily stressed by factors such as development, anti-migration borders, socio-economic positioning and political marginalization. If we are serious about adaptation, there is much restructuring work to be done.
[Closing speech by Myrna Cunningham, Chair of UN Permanent Forum of Indigenous Issues]
Secondly, in my view, it was evident, that in order to work with Indigenous cultural knowledge appropriately, there was enormous capacity building needed amongst higher education institutions. In particular, capacity building that centred around equity and authorship amongst both Indigenous and non-indigenous collaborators. I think days should be numbered for the classic old school research methods of modern/western expert scientist and indigenous community research participant. There is much to learn, share, mentor and support, but as wise Peruvian Dr Tirso Gonzales said to me, there is no google translator for an indigenous person’s environmental understanding. Perhaps an interesting capacity building transition phase may be similar to Indigenous film-making protocols, whereby seeking Indigenous collaborators/partners or rough draft approval with knowledge custodians is an essential element of the project’s funding process.
If we truly are to move to a post-enlightenment society, capacity building must start by institutional acknowledgment of Indigenous intellectual property, custodial rights, human rights, territorial rights and Indigenous self-determination.
[..and some cultural activities such as Mexician feasting with some of my colleagues]
Now in the midst of an essay for “Ecological responses to climate change”, i wanted to share this seminal research paper published in NATURE back in 2006.
… we predict, on the basis of mid-range climate-warming scenarios for 2050,that 15-37% of species [covering some 20% of the Earth’s terrestrial surface] will be ‘committed to extinction’…
no, no, NO! everybody, this level of extinction is not OK.
Because, its likely to include some of the insect species that pollinate our food, or the microbes that fertilise our agricultural soil, or the phyto-plankton species that sustain our fish. If you are skeptic, or even denier [god bless you], its important to understand there is already an ecological “signal” happening here….I’m talking about ECOLOGY RESPONSES…observations from field ecologists and citizen species monitoring groups (bird watchers, local farmers, bushwalkers etc) around the world, already recording shifts in ecological seasonal flowering times, migrations and location distributions. The very web of life is morphing. Its scary epic.
So what can we each do??? Well, its kinda easy and kinda hard, kick the excessive consumption addiction. Make efforts to live smaller, and at peace with natural surroundings. buy only what you really need. Be aware. Did your new stuff arrive by plane, train, truck or foot. Sadly, its crunch time, because our socially conditioned desire for stuff (eg. buy, consume, dump) is shortly going to be OUR food problem.
To let an expert illustrate the situation’s gravity, here’s a very informative interview we did with one of the world’s top Ecology Professors Jose Sarukan Kermez at the UNU back in 2009.
I heard the term, “culture before fact” from Professor Hulme, and perhaps this simple phrase helps explain why we disagree (and continue to disagree) about climate change.
Discussions were diverse (if slightly euro-centric) touching on art history and notions of landscape framing; the histories of the scientific worldview, and the still enduring “enlightenment” quest to conquer/summit and take apart the ‘mechanisms” of the world; to ecologists from Mexico exploring local ecological understandings of ocean/earth/sky systems in preparation for future extreme hurricane events; to geologists exploring the environmental history of a place through UK soil layers; to archeologists tracing bronze age societal frameworks as sea levels, river systems, diets and dwelling structure changes in Britain; to a British anthropologist and American bird neuro-endocrinologist working together on the Tibetan plateau discovering the deep importance of Indigenous climate/environment histories and cultural worldviews within the research material.
How we have evolved to relate to climate and its previous effects on us, shapes how we view and engage with future climates. Perhaps your ideas and cultural ways of interpreting and relating to climate “evidence”, differs from a woman in the Mongolian Gobi.
At the finale of two days, I had a strong intuition to continue exploring these ideas, perhaps being part of a movement to help “crowbar” apart the climate discussion which is currently nailed as a “discovery” and problem of scientists and economists , and further open it out for the fresh air of our “humanitarian” scientists (and maybe farmers, healers, poets, chefs, women’s knitting circles, taxi drivers, kindergarteners, hunters, navigators and storytellers)
But just how this will happen, is a hard vision to grasp.
What can multiple climate histories and the different cultural goggles we wear, tell us about ourselves and our relationship with nature? But more importantly, how can these differing cultural perspectives be respected and seated next to each other, in order to create new forms of governance, environmental understanding, science, worldview approaches… or consciousness… shared and diverse understandings from the past, that inform us of what we progressively could do.
To find out more about the conference speakers, or to read any of the session papers.
Flying out to Bonn, Germany today to attend the Deutsche Welle Global Media Forum. This year’s forum is focusing on the role of the media towards the issues of Climate Change. We will be giving a presentation on the last day. Here is the latest 1 minute trailer of our work.